Court Clears Ritual, Bare Handed Killing of a Bull – Does the Judgement Threaten Wider Environmental Problems?
Yesterday, a “thanksgiving” festival for the seasons first fruits included the killing of a black Nguni bull by hand by 40 young men, after legal attempts to stop it failed. The annual festival was hosted by King Zwelithini of the Zulu Nation and attended by President Jacob Zuma of South Africa and other dignitaries.
Nguni Cattle
More South Africans Lean About Ukweshwama
A few days ago firebrand Julius Malema, the President of the ANC Youth League, said three times to reporter Deborah Patta that she knew nothing of the Pedi traditions. While we often like to not hear what Malema has to say, and he certainly knows little of the traditions of English South Africans, his words rang true given the storm now raging in South Africa over the Ukweshwama festival that includes the barehanded ritual slaughter of a bull by a group of 40 young men.
Legal actions by Animal Rights Africa this year brought the practice to the fore in South Africa as they struggled to halt the practice after some years of trying to convince the Royal House and Government.I need to personally admit that, although I was brought up in KwaZulu Natal and worked in rural Zululand with Zulu Chiefs, I had never heard of this particular ceremony. I did once witness a Zulu prince eating uncooked liver from a bull that had been slaughtered in response to the Princes ruling in a traditional court, so was not completely isolated.
Ukweshwama the First Fruits Festival
King Zwelithini’s Facebook page states
“His Majesty is especially elated about the pivotal role he has played in reviving the culture and traditions that had served as the bedrock upon which the Zulu Empire was founded. The Reed Dance, “First Fruits” festival and hunting ceremony have helped the present generation within the kingdom to merge modernism with tradition.”
According to tradition, subjects have to offer their “first fruits” to their king before they could use the new harvest. This was formalised in the Ukweshwama festival, that was held at the King’s palace and also served as a thanksgiving to God for providing food for the nation.
The Ukweshwama festival is one of great joy and cultural song and dance, that reflects the Zulu nation celebrating the fact that they can look forward to a good harvest and ample food in the kingdom. A major highlight of the festival is the ritual killing of a bull by 40 young men with their bare hands. This is not a quick humane slaughter but can be a protracted 40 minute struggle, where the bull is throttled death or has its neck broken. It was originally seen as a test of young men’s courage and bravery and a chance for the warriors to prove themselves. The power of the bull was supposedly transferred to those who took its life and via them the king.
Ukweshwama 2009
For some time Animal Rights Africa attempted to initiate discussions on the acceptability of going ahead with a ceremony which they judge to be cruel to the bull. They addressed the Royal Household and government bodies they felt appropriate, but got little response. They recently contacted all these parties and noted that they were going to take legal steps and again received no response. Once their application reached the court these parties requested time to make submissions which were taken into account by the judge in reaching his judgement.
A suggestion by the judge that the ceremony is video taped so that it could later be examined to decide whether it was cruel or not was refused by the respondents.
During his judgement in the Pietermaritzburg High Court, Judge Nic van der Reyden allowed the festival to continue because he was satisfied with the evidence of cultural expert Professor Jabulani Mapalala. Mapalala said that the the animal’s death was quick, unpainful and that no blood was shed and claimed that ARA’s objection to the ritual was based on untrue information and hearsay.
There seems to be some doubt around Mapalala’s interpretation of painful and quick. For instance an article in an ANC newsletter of December 1995, quotes Chief Mlaba saying
“We must use our bare hands, It’s cruelty, we agree, but it’s our culture. We cannot change our culture.”
and describes the action
“For 40 minutes, dozens trampled the bellowing, groaning bull, wrenched its head around by the horns to try to break its neck, pulled its tongue out, stuffed sand in its mouth and even tried to tie its penis in a knot. Gleaming with sweat, they raised their arms in triumph and sang when the bull finally succumbed.”
Attempts by animal rights organisations were seen as “racist actions” against the Zulu nation, while the animal rights the killing as cruel and unnecessary – a culture gap.
The Dangers of This Culture Gap
At the heart of this story lies an enormous culture gap which both sides are unready to reconsider. Such gaps between accepted “western world practices” and the rights of tradition, also occur in other areas such as conservation, and the environment where they could have a detrimental impact.
The over exploitation of many plant species for cultural uses as medicine/potions is well documented in South Africa. Animal parts are also used in traditional medicine raising the danger of a conflict between tradition and the conservation of species.
Even more disturbing are the cases of human body part being used in traditional medicine with recent cases of albinos in Nigeria and twins in Ghana being murdered, highlighting horrendous acts in the name of tradition.
On a lighter side (because the slaughter could be well controlled and humane) the Makhonya Royal Trust has proposed that cattle killing ritual are used as a “true African” way of blessing the stadiums to be used in 2010 World Cup in South Africa, but minister Sicelo Shiceka has promised to lobby Fifa to support this action.
photo by justinjerez on Wikipedia under a Creative Commons License.
This is truly barbaric! To think of the torture and horrific pain that animal endured is beyond imagination. Why do these people they have the right to inflict this kind of pain and torture on another living being?
NO GOD advocates violence and torture. NO GOD advocates this kind of ritualistic satanic practice. This clearly of the devil!
A Holiday Thought…
Aren’t humans amazing Animals? They kill wildlife – birds, deer, all kinds of cats, coyotes, beavers, groundhogs, mice and foxes by the million in order to protect their domestic animals and their feed.
Then they kill domestic animals by the billion and eat them. This in turn kills people by the million, because eating all those animals leads to degenerative – and fatal – - health conditions like heart disease, stroke, kidney disease, and cancer.
So then humans spend billions of dollars torturing and killing millions of more animals to look for cures for these diseases.
Elsewhere, millions of other human beings are being killed by hunger and malnutrition because food they could eat is being used to fatten domestic animals.
Meanwhile, few people recognize the absurdity of humans, who kill so easily and violently, and once a year send out cards praying for “Peace on Earth.”
~Revised Preface to Old MacDonald’s Factory Farm by C. David Coates~
This is one bull a year?
Am I missing something?
Well, Bob – maybe basic common decency and compassion for starters.
The torment that ONE bull must have endured simply doesn’t bear thinking about – would it make a difference to your indifference if it were, say ten bulls – a hundred? Sadism and bloodlust against one animal or one thousand are simply unacceptable to any civilised individual, in any CIVILISED society.
One of the most savage, primitive, and inhuman acts of sheer brutality I have ever heard of.
Just WHEN does this country intend to become part of civilization?
Someone please inform them that this is the 21st century!
Good question Dee. I share your outrage. But while we’re about it, let’s also inform ‘civilized’ Spain that its the 21st Century, who still does their version of man against bull for public sport, and Denmark who are guilty of mass dolphin slaughter, and China for their bile bear and other atrocities, the Royal family of UK who are still partial to fox-hunting, parts of America where pitbull fighting is a masculine kind of pastime etc etc.