Three different news items highlight the vast differences in viewpoint and the continuing uncertainty around the farming of Jatropha by small scale farmers as a feedstock for Europe’s refineries moving towards meeting the EU’s renewable liquid fuel goals.
Clarity on What Jatropha Can Deliver
At the recent Africa Biofuels Conference in Midrand South Africa, Vincent Volckaert the Regional Manager for Africa of D1 Oils Plant Science presented a paper titled “Jatropha curcas: beyond the myth of the miracle crop”.
Besides making it clear that Jatropha is not a miracle plant and like any other it needs water and fertiliser to produce biomass, he noted it was particularly sensitive to pests and disease when not grown as an intercrop. Volckaert stated that D1 Oil expected to release new seed in 2010 or 2011, that would have a yield of 2 tons of oil per hectare on well managed estates at maturity.The information in this paper needs to be seen against the background of D1 Oils’ experience in the Jatropha biodiesel sector. D1 Oils were unable to meet their initial business targets and were forced to adjust strategy and sell production facilities mainly. Much of this appears to be related to their inability to deliver the Jatropha oil they had projected when they first contracted farmers in Africa and India.
But Africa Just Carries On
At a recent meeting with farmers in Uyo, Chief Michael Udo Akpan, the Chairman of the Akwa Ibom branch of the All Farmers Association of Nigeria (AFAN), stated that “Jatropha grows short and adapts to all weather conditions so you farmers should as a matter of urgency commence cultivation”.
[social buttons]He further claimed that a hectare of land is capable of producing “more than 226 gallons of biodiesel” and that trees had a lifespan of 40-50 years, can be harvested three times in a year and could “do well on any type of soil”.
His claim which is equivalent to 10,106 litres when compared to D1 Oil expectations from their new seed of only 2,558 makes a massive difference to the potential of farming.
This is unfortunately a typical African development scenario which is based on unfounded optimism, implemented/promoted by those not directly effected and typically leaves the already struggling farmer to suffer.
And Perceptions are What Drives Small Farmer’s Actions
Friends of the Earth (FOE) have published a report cautioning that the widespread introduction of Jatropha by D1 Oils through the contracting of small scale farmers in Swaziland might be counterproductive. They call on the EU to include a thorough analysis of Jatropha in its 2010 report on indirect land use change due to biofuel production and the UK Government to carry out an urgent review into the current impacts of biofuels in developing countries for crops. They also call on the EU to put biofuel targets on hold until it can be proven that they can be met sustainably and D1 Oils to halt production while Environmental Impact Assesments (EIA) are undertaken.
They make a strong statement that Jatropha cannot currently be considered a sustainable biofuel crop because its supposed benefits are unproven.
D1 Oils has responded to Biofuels Review by admitting much of the report’s information regarding the negative aspects of Jatropha farming for biofuel is valid for biofuel but makes a number of statements, intended to deflect criticism, which deserve some analysis.
“We have made very clear in our recent materials that marginal land is likely to deliver only marginal yields. We have never claimed that Jatropha is a plant-and-forget crop” - its clear they have, even if inadvertently, contributed much to the “Jatropha hype” that has swept through countries looking for quick and easy development solutions. After all they were essentially mislead by what they expected from Jatropha.
“We monitor closely how farmers are planting the crop and we do not encourage planting on food grade land. We aim to work to the highest standards in partnership with local people” - as outlined in a previous post, even with the best of intensions, it takes real serious effort to protect the interests of farmers’ especially when objectives are essentially contrary. According to grassroots NGOs in Swaziland there have been difficulties in meeting these implementation goals.
“We disagree fundamentally with FOE’s conclusion that Jatropha development should be halted because not enough is known of the crop” – FOE seem only to say they should halt production until appropriate EIA’s prove sustainability and D1 Oils have anyway effectively already halted production in Swaziland by withdrawing to “as part of the reorganisation of the business that is currently underway”. A disquitening comment here was a statement that FOE must understand that to achieve progress risk must be taken. FOEs constituency, the small scale farmers, need to be carefuly protected and can not suffer while other try things out.
What Are The Implications
These stories, like a growing number of reports, confirm that Jatropha is not realising the oil yields that drove the “Jatropha euphoria” and that it never can while the plantings are based on wild seeds. Like any other crop Jatropha needs development to come to a stage where it can predictably produce oil to feed a biodiesel industry.
It needs to asked again if the industry is repeating this kind of “Jatropha euphoria” with other biofuels like algal biodiesel and cellulosic ethanol which will eventually lead to the same disillusion.
Photo Credit: By edwardyanquen on flickr under a Creative Commons license.
The promotion of Jatropha is clearly being motivated by another agenda that doesn’t serve the interests of the farmers and alternative fuels. It’s unfortunate that farmers aren’t more cynical about a plant that promises to grow with no water and poor soil.
http://tinyurl.com/lzm6al
Hi Marcus – Just think about many of the biomass plants being praised – many have the same blurb going for them.
To often idealists jump on something and then common sense goes out the window.
Here is a TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPED IN THE UNIVERSITY OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES, BANGALORE, which can readily solve the problem in the production of First and Second generation of biofuels at global level, in a span of 20 years, that too in a sustainable way. This technology can also address food security for poor, small scale, resource-limited farmers including women. Simarouba cultivation improves soil fertility by adding organic matter to the soil. Introduction of this rainfed water prudent tree crop acts as a supplement to the regular income and helps in retaining the crop diversity. This technology can be easily adopted to surmount hunger problem at individual as well as at global level. It is a low budget agriculture technology suitable for ecologic farming and does not require intense training. It addresses the problems of biofuel generation, hunger, poverty and agricultural production in many poor countries of the tropical world. The visionaries in NCB, FAO, WHO, ICRAF, CGIAR and other organizations have to recognize the importance of this technology and implement it systematically and effectively to usher evergreen revolution.
——“SIMAROUBA GLAUCA CULTIVATION FOR EVERGREEN REVOLUTION”——-
THIS WORKABLE SYSTEM CAN BE EASILY ADOPTED EVEN IN AFRICAN COUNTRIES AT GLOBAL LEVEL. This versatile tree can be easily grown as an intercrop along with the traditional annual crops without decreasing the regular annual food production. Once established, this ecofriendly tree showers following benefits on growers every year for more than 60 years, irrespective of erratic rainfall. 1. The seeds give about one ton good quality edible oil worth about Rs.30,000/ha/year. 2. The surplus oil produced can be easily trans-esterified and converted into biodiesel (FIRST GENERATION BIOFUELS) to take care of the very much needed energy requirements. 3. The oilcake (one ton/ha/year) with about 8% nitrogen is good organic manure that can fulfill the fertiliser requirements of the farmers. Its money value is about Rs.10,000/ha 4. The fruit pulp with about 12% sugar can produce as much as 10,000 liters of beverage/ha/year. The waste fruit pulp also can be gainfully employed to manufacture ethanol (to blend with petrol) (FIRST GENERATION BIOFUELS). The agricultural waste (biomass) such as shell, unwanted branches, and leaf litter (about 15 tons/ha) can be easily used to produce SECOND GENERATION BIOFUELS. This carbon neutral technology is perfectly sustainable and for the production of biofuels there is no need to destroy the virgin forests. Instead these trees help in preserving the forests since the pressure on the demand for wood is easily met by the fast growing Simarouba. 5. The leaf litter is relished very much by earthworms and it can be used to produce vermicompost or compost of about 10 tons/ha/year worth Rs.30,000/ha. 6. From about 500 trees in a hectare the farmer can fell about 25 trees every year and sell for about Rs.25,000/- as it is good timber as well as fuel wood. 7. APART FROM THESE MONETARY BENEFITS, THE DECOCTION FROM LEAVES OF THE TREE (HARVESTED IN A SUSTAINABLE MANNER) IS PROVEN ANTIVIRAL, ANTIBACTERIAL, ANTIAMOEBIC, ANTIMALARIAL, ANTIHELMENTIC, ANTIULCEROUS, ANTITUMOROUS, ANTICANCEROUS, ANTILEUKEMIC. THIS ENABLES THE POOR VILLAGERS TO HAVE EASY ACCESS TO CURE MANY HUMAN AND LIVESTOCK AILMENTS WITH ALMOST NO FINANCIAL BURDEN. 8. Cultivation of this tree as an intercrop without disturbing the regular food production gives an additional financial benefit of Rs.50,000/ha/year every year without fail, irrespective of the vagaries in rainfall. Thus, it gives stability at microeconomics level to the poor farmers. 9. A nation like India with about 140 million ha of land (dryland and wasteland put together) can easily attain self sufficiency in the production of edible oil, biodiesel, organic fertilisers, vermicompost, timber, just in a matter of two decades and attain stability at macroeconomics level. 10. To establish one tree it requires just Re.one only, that is Rs.500/ha, to an actual cultivator. The gestation period is about 5 years and it attains stability in production by about 10 years. 11. Its cultivation helps in establishing industries concerned to the production of first and second generation biofuels, edible oil, vegetable butter, margarine, lubricants, soaps, shampoos, other cosmetics, beverages, electricity, thermal power generation, timber, pharmaceuticals etc. at village level and thus helps in creating income generating green jobs to crores of villagers. This gives livelihood to about 30% of the population.12. This evergreen tree cultivation helps in preventing soil erosion, improving ground water position, combating desertification and checking greenhouse effect and global warming. 13. AFTER ATTAINING ECONOMIC PROSPERITY, THE VILLAGERS MAY BE ADVISED TO ESTABLISH THEIR OWN STANDARD EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS AT THE RURAL LEVEL INVITING THE DEDICATED AND EFFICIENT TEACHERS TO IMPART BEST EDUCATION TO THEIR CHILDREN. THIS WILL AUTOMATICALLY SOLVE THE PROBLEMS OF POPULATION EXPLOSON AND THREATENING POLLUTION. The additional money generated at the rural level may also be wisely invested in developing infrastructure such as water supply, sanitation, incessant electricity supply, medical facilities, transport etc. ALL THESE RESULT IN ECONOMIC SECURITY, FOOD SECURITY, BIOMANURE SECURITY, HEALTH SECURITY, FUEL SECURITY, POWER (ELECTRICITY) SECURITY, EDUCATIONAL SECURITY, EMPLOYMENT SECURITY AND ENVIRONMENTAL SECURITY AT THE RURAL AND GLOBAL LEVEL. This discourages villagers from migrating to urban areas. No wonder if reverse migration begins to take place from urban to rural areas in due course of time. References: Google search: Simarouba glauca cultivation; Simarouba medicine; Simarouba glauca – Wikipedia; Simarouba Bangalore Mirror. Contact address: Dr. Syamasundar Joshi and Dr. Shantha Joshi; 23, R.B.I. Colony, Anandanagar, Bangalore; Mob:(0)94486 84021; E mail joshi.sim@gmail.com